| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 2010 | Torii Hunter, OF |
| 2009 | Brian Fuentes, P; Chone Figgins, 3B; Torii Hunter, OF |
| 2008 | Ervin Santana, P; Joe Saunders, P; Francisco Rodriguez, P |
| 2007 | Vladimir Guerrero, OF; John Lackey, P; Francisco Rodriguez, P |
| 2006 | Vladimir Guerrero, OF |
| 2005 | Vladimir Guerrero, OF; Garret Anderson, OF; Bartolo Colon, P |
| 2004 | Vladimir Guerrero, OF; Francisco Rodriguez, P |
| 2003 | Troy Glaus, 3B; Brendan Donnelly, P; Garret Anderson, OF; Mike Scioscia, Manager; Alfredo Griffin, Coach; Mickey Hatcher, Coach; Ron Roenicke, Coach; Orlando Mercado, Coach; Bud Black, Coach; Steve Soliz, Coach; Joe Maddon, Coach |
| 2002 | Garret Anderson, OF; Mike Scioscia, Coach |
| 2001 | Troy Glaus, 3B; Troy Percival, P |
| 2000 | Darin Erstad, OF; Troy Glaus, 3B |
| 1999 | Troy Percival, P |
| 1998 | Troy Percival, P; Darin Erstad, OF |
| 1997 | Jason Dickson, P; Rick Smith, Trainer |
| 1996 | Chuck Finley, P; Troy Percival, P |
| 1995 | Jim Edmonds, OF; Chuck Finley, P; Lee Smith, P; Gary DiSarcina, SS |
| 1994 | Chili Davis, DH |
| 1993 | Mark Langston, P |
| 1992 | Mark Langston, P; Jimmie Reese, Honorary Captain; Rick Turner, Bullpen Coach; Ned Bergert, Trainer |
| 1991 | Bryan Harvey, P; Mark Langston, P |
| 1990 | Chuck Finley, P; Lance Parrish, C |
| 1989 | Chuck Finley, P; Devon White, OF; Doug Rader, Coach; Marcel Lachemann, Coach; Rick Smith, Trainer |
| 1988 | Johnny Ray, OF |
| 1987 | Mike Witt, P |
| 1986 | Wally Joyner, 1B; Mike Witt, P |
| 1985 | Donnie Moore, P |
| 1984 | Rod Carew, 1B; Reggie Jackson, OF; Rick Smith, Trainer |
| 1983 | Rod Carew, 1B; Reggie Jackson, OF; Fred Lynn, OF; Doug DeCinces, 3B; Bob Boone, C |
| 1982 | Rod Carew, 1B; Reggie Jackson, OF; Fred Lynn, OF; Bobby Grich, 2B |
| 1981 | Rod Carew, 1B; Fred Lynn, OF; Rick Burleson, SS; Ken Forsch, P; Jimmie Reese, Coach |
| 1980 | Rod Carew, 1B; Bobby Grich, 2B; Bob Clear, Coach |
| 1979 | Rod Carew, 1B; Bobby Grich, 2B; Brian Downing, C; Don Baylor, DH; Nolan Ryan, P; Mark Clear, P |
| 1978 | Frank Tanana, P |
| 1977 | Frank Tanana (replaced Dave LaRoche, who replaced Nolan Ryan), P |
| 1976 | Frank Tanana, P |
| 1975 | Dave Chalk, 3B; Nolan Ryan, P |
| 1974 | Dave Chalk, 3B; Frank Robinson, OF; Dick Williams, Manager; Freddie Frederico, Trainer; Whitey Herzog, Coach |
| 1973 | Nolan Ryan, P; Bill Singer, P |
| 1972 | Nolan Ryan, P |
| 1971 | Andy Messersmith, P |
| 1970 | Sandy Alomar, 2B; Jim Fregosi, SS; Alex Johnson, OF; Clyde Wright, P; Lefty Phillips, Coach |
| 1969 | Jim Fregosi, SS |
| 1968 | Jim Fregosi, SS |
| 1967 | Jim McGlothlin, P; Don Mincher, P; Jim Fregosi, SS |
| 1966 | Jim Fregosi, SS; Bobby Knoop, 2B |
| 1965 | Bob Lee, P |
| 1964 | Jim Fregosi, SS; Dean Chance, P |
| 1963 | Ken McBride, P; Albie Pearson, OF; Leon Wagner, OF |
| 1962 | Leon Wagner (both games), OF; Billy Moran (both games), 2B; Lee Thomas (both games), OF; Ken McBride (second game), P; Bill Rigney, Coach |
| 1961 | Ryne Duren (first game), P; Ken McBride (both games), P |
